ETFs vs. Index Funds: Which Are Better?
Index FundsAn index fund is a "passively" managed mutual fund that tries to mirror the performance of a specific index, such as the S&P 500 or the Dow Jones Industrial Average. Since index funds attempt to mirror a stock index, decisions about which stocks to buy and sell are automatic for the fund and transactions are infrequent. This means that index funds do not require the management of a professional money manager, and so they are said to be "passively managed" (while any fund that requires a manager to select stocks is said to be "actively managed").
Index funds have become increasingly popular with investors over the past few decades for a variety of reasons.
Many investors also like index funds because they do not have to worry about "beating the market" since they can choose to invest in an index that mirrors the market (either the market as a whole or some specific part of it). But although you'll never significantly underperform the market with an index fund, you'll also never have the opportunity to significantly outperform it. Even so, as more and more studies have shown that most mutual fund managers are unable to beat the market consistently, more and more investors have been starting to take advantage of index funds. For individuals who don't have the time or interest to select and monitor a portfolio of actively managed mutual funds, we recommend seriously considering index funds.
Exchange-Traded FundsExchange-traded funds (ETFs) are similar to index funds, but with one important distinction: they trade on stock exchanges. When you buy a share in an ETF, you are buying a share in a unit investment trust or another type of trust . In order to create an ETF, the trust bundles together many different securities into one basket and then sells shares in the trust on a stock exchange. ETFs always bundle together the securities that are in an index; they never track actively managed mutual fund portfolios (because most actively managed funds only disclose their holdings a few times a year, so the ETF would not know when to adjust its holdings most of the time). Investors can do anything with an ETF that they can do with a normal stock, such as short selling.
Because ETFs are traded on stock exchanges, you can buy and sell them at any time during the day (unlike most mutual funds). Their price will fluctuate from moment to moment, just like any other stock's price, and you'll need a broker in order to purchase them, which means that you'll have to pay a commission. On the plus side, though, ETFs are more tax-efficient than normal mutual funds, and since they track indexes they have very low operating and transaction costs associated with them. There are no sales loads or investment minimums required to purchase an ETF.
The first ETF created was the Standard and Poor's Deposit Receipt (SPDR, pronounced "spider") in 1993. SPDRs gave investors an easy way to track the S&P 500 without buying an index fund, and they soon become quite popular. Shortly thereafter, a number of other ETFs came onto the market, including "cubes" (which track the Nasdaq 100 under the symbol QQQ) and "diamonds" (which track the Dow under the symbol DIA). Today you can buy ETFs for dozens of different indexes.
Posted in ...Investing